Throughout National Cybersecurity Awareness Month, a massive flood of advice went out across the digital world telling consumers to be careful. Don’t click the link. Don’t share the code. Hang up and call back.
None of that is wrong, of course. But it also carries an assumption the financial industry should question: that the account holder is the last line of defense.
The perfect login
An account holder gets a call from “the fraud department.” The caller ID shows her financial institution’s number. The caller knows the last four digits of her card and a purchase she made yesterday. Her account has been compromised, the rep says, and the she needs to move her savings to a protected account right now.
So she logs in with a passkey, on the phone she’s had for three years, from her home Wi-Fi. She adds a new payee and sends $9,500.
Every control did exactly what it was designed to do — and not one of them was designed for this. That’s not an edge case. That’s the scammers’ playbook.
U.S. consumers reported losing $3.5 billion to imposter scams in 2025, nearly triple the figure from 2020. Financial institution (FI) impersonators led the losses among business impersonators. According to the FTC, some of the costliest scams start with a fake security alert, often from an FI, that convinces people to move their money to “protect” it.
Fraud follows the path of least resistance
The industry is getting much better at confirming who is logging in. Here’s the uncomfortable consequence of that: when you close the door on account takeover, fraud doesn’t just disappear. It simply moves on to the one door you can’t lock: persuasion.
The U.K. shows where this goes. In 2025, unauthorized fraud losses there fell 5%. Over the same period, authorized push payment fraud, where the real account holder is manipulated into sending the money themselves, rose 19% to £576 million ($775 million). As the controls got stronger, criminals stopped trying to beat them and started talking account holders through them.
In a scam, the right person is on the right device, doing the “wrong” thing because someone is coaching them.
Awareness is not a control
Consumer education matters. But think about what we’re asking: that a frightened person recognize manipulation while it’s happening, from a fraudster whose whole playbook (urgency, authority and isolation) is built to shut down careful thinking.
The people we most want to protect are exactly who scammers target.
A cybersecurity tip that someone read in October doesn’t help them in March at 4:45 p.m. with a “bank investigator” on the line. At the moment of decision, the account holder’s judgment is compromised.
The one party that’s still clear-headed, though, is the platform.
Coercion leaves fingerprints
A scammed session is a real person on a real device, but it rarely looks like that person on an ordinary day. They hesitate. They move through unfamiliar screens with odd precision. They make the largest transfer in the account’s history to a payee created minutes earlier.
No single one of these behaviors is fraud, but the pattern is. And spotting it is becoming possible. What the industry hasn’t figured out yet is what to do next.
The intervention is the product
Most step-up challenges are built to verify identity, and against a scam, that’s the wrong tool:
- A one-time passcode fails. The scammer tells the victim to read it aloud.
- An “Are you sure?” box fails. They’ve been told to click “yes.”
- A temporary account lock often fails. It looks exactly like what the scammer said would happen.
Every generic challenge assumes the person answering it is on our side. The intervention has to be specific enough to break the script:
- Name the scam out loud. “Has someone asked you to move money to keep it safe? That’s a scam. We will never ask you to do this.”
- Add a pause the scammer can’t talk the victim through. Time works against manipulation.
- Bring in a person. At the most dangerous moments, a trusted human voice from the institution beats any prompt.
- Match the response to the stakes. A first-time payment that empties a savings account deserves different handling than a routine bill pay.
That changes how we should measure success. The number that matters most is how many people have been successfully stopped.
There’s no hindsight in scam prevention
When the account holder authorized the payment themselves, getting the money back is slow, uncertain and often impossible. As payments get faster, the window to act shrinks from days to seconds. A fraud alert that fires after the payment settles isn’t prevention, it’s paperwork.
That makes the moment before “send” the most valuable moment in fraud prevention—and the one most fraud programs still treat as an afterthought.
What we’re building
We’re keeping all this in mind as we build Votiv Protect within the Candescent Intelligent Banking platform. Strong, modern login is the foundation. On top of it, we orchestrate signals from leading partners in behavioral intelligence, digital impersonation protection and enterprise fraud and transaction monitoring. That lets the platform answer the harder question of whether the person is acting freely and gives it the ability to step in when it matters most.
This past October, plenty of cybersecurity campaigns told consumers to protect themselves. They should. But the financial institutions that win the next decade will be the ones that stop asking account holders to be their own last line of defense and start protecting them from scams and risks proactively, rapidly and intelligently.



